June 14, 2007
Americans Unready to Revolt, Despite Revolting Conditions
by Joel S. Hirschhorn
The latest NBC/Wall Street Journal
national poll results vividly show a population incredibly dissatisfied with
their nation’s political system. In other countries in other times such a
depressing level of confidence in government would send a signal to those
running the government that a major upheaval is imminent. But not here in the
USA. Why?
First, here are the highlights of the poll that surveyed 1,008 adults from June
8-11, with a margin of error of plus-minus 3.1 percentage points.
A whopping 68 percent think the country is on the wrong track. Just 19
percent believe the country is headed in the right direction - the lowest number
on that question in nearly 15 years. And most of those with the positive view
are probably in the Upper Class.
Bush’s approval rating is at just 29 percent, his lowest mark ever in the
survey. Only 62 percent of Republicans approve, versus 32 percent who
disapprove. Take Republicans out of the picture and a fifth or less of
Americans have a positive view of Bush.
Even worse, only 23 percent approve of the job that Congress is doing. So much
for that wonderful new Democratic control of Congress. Bipartisan incompetence
is alive and well.
On the economic front, nearly twice as many people think the U.S. is more hurt
than helped by the global economy (48 to 25 percent).
Globalization does not spread wealth; it channels it to the wealthy, making
billionaires out of millionaires.
I have long asserted that Americans live in a delusional democracy with
delusional prosperity and these and loads of other data support this view.
There is a super wealthy and politically powerful Upper Class that is literally
raping the nation. Meanwhile, the huge Lower Class continues to lose economic
ground while their elected representatives sell them out to benefit the Upper
Class. Yet no rational person thinks that a large fraction of the population is
ready to rise up in revolt against the evil status quo political-economic system
that so clearly is not serving the interests of the overwhelming majority of
Americans. Why not?
For a nation that was built on a revolt against oppressive governance by the
British, something has been lost from our political DNA. We apparently no
longer have the gene for political rebellion. It has been bred out of most of
us. And those of us that urge a Second American Revolution are seen as fringe,
nutty subversives.
Part of the genius of our contemporary ruling class elites is that they have
engineering a state of political and economic oppression that paradoxically is
still embraced by the Lower Class. The rational way to understand this is that
ordinary, oppressed Americans are in a deep psychological state of
self-delusion. Despite all the empirical, objective evidence of a failed
government, they fail to see rebellion opportunities. Many still believe they
live in the world’s best democracy. But across all elections considerably less
than half the citizens even bother to vote anymore. Yet, as the new NBC/Journal
poll results show, people are cognitively aware of just how awful the
political-economic system is. Yet they are not feeling enough pain to seriously
consider rebellion. And it is visceral pain that must drive people to the
daring act of rebellion.
Why is there insufficient pain for revolution? This is a deadly serious issue.
What is historically unique about America is that even the most oppressed and
unfairly treated people are distracted by affordable materialism, entertainment,
sports, gambling, and myriad other aspects of our frivolous, self-absorbed
culture. Even failed school and health care systems do not drive people, paying
enormous sums to fill up their SUVs, to rebellion. So, Americans are aware of
their oppression, but the power elites have successfully drugged them with a
plethora of pleasure-producing distractions sufficient to keep them under
control. We are free to bitch, but too weak to revolt. The Internet has
provided a release valve for some pent up anger and frustration. But it too has
mostly become another source of distraction, rather than an effective tool for
rebellion.
Though these new poll statistics make news, those in control of the
political-economic system are not afraid that the population is on the verge of
retaking their constitutionally guaranteed sovereign power and take back their
nation. Thousands of people like me keep writing books and articles and
creating protest groups and events. Those in power just find new, ingenious
ways to keep the population distracted – if not through pleasure, then certainly
through fear of terrorism. Growing economic insecurity also contributes to
self-paralysis, as do never-ending political lies.
What a system.
Even as the population has growing awareness of the dire condition of their
nation, the move by the politically powerful on the right and left continues to
seek a new immigration law that will solidify the selling out of America.
Business interests want more of those fleeing Mexico and other nations to keep
wages low. Instead of Mexicans rising up in rebellion against their oppressive
government and economic system they escape to the USA. But Americans have no
such viable escape solution. Though global warming will certainly make Canada
increasingly attractive.
So what do Americans have – other than a terribly bleak future? Where is hope
in our dismal world?
In a bizarre twist of history that further illustrates just how impotent
Americans have become, virtually all citizens are either unaware of or
unreceptive to the ultimate escape route that the Framers of our Constitution
gave us. They anticipated that Americans could become quite dissatisfied with
the federal government. They feared that the political system could become
incredibly corrupted by moneyed interests. They were right.
So here we sit over 200 years after our nation was created unwilling to use what
is explicitly given to us in Article V of the Constitution – the option to have
a convention outside the control of Congress, the President and the Supreme
Court to make proposals for constitutional amendments. Do we really believe in
the rule of law? If so, then we should understand that the supreme law of the
land – what is in our Constitution – is the ultimate way to obtain the deep
political and government reforms to restore true democracy and economic fairness
to our society.
Make no mistake: an Article V convention has been stubbornly opposed by
virtually all groups with political and economic power. This is most evidenced
by the blatant refusal of Congress to obey the Constitution and give us an
Article V convention, even though the single explicit requirement for a
convention has been met. This fact alone should tell rational people that they
are being screwed and oppressed. The rule of law is trumped by the rule of
delusion. Our lawmakers are lawbreakers.
Come learn more about the effort to get an Article V convention at
www.foavc.org and become a member. Do not
keep witnessing the unraveling of American society, voting for lesser evil
candidates, and believing the propaganda that putting different Democrats or
Republicans in office will actually improve things for most of us. Choose
peaceful rebellion by using what our Constitution gives us. Fight
self-delusion.
[Joel S. Hirschhorn is the author of Delusional Democracy (www.delusionaldemocracy.com); and a founder of Friends of the Article V Convention (www.foavc.org).]